Romeo and juliet, though termed as tragedy carries more of shakespeares comedy elements. Watching the scene 3 times prepares them for a lesson in figurative language and a discussion of literature vs. Compare two film versions of romeo and juliet a comparison grid and essay frame focusing on the fight scene in act 1 scene 1. The 1968 version and the controversial 1996 version give different perspectives of shakespeares famous play. When i was asked to compare baz luhrmanns and franco zefirellis versions of romeo and juliet one out of many things drastically separates the two videos for me. Romeo and juliet movie comparison paper campbell2015. Romeo and juliet is one of william shakespeares greatest love stories and also unfortunately tragedy. This opens up a bunch of fun and criticalthinking conversation about why the film makers would change parts of the play for the film. Romeo and juliet balcony scene comparison the jiblog. This is a textbook way to film first encounters between lovers. Explain how these costumes are appropriate for each character, giving special attention to analyzing paris outfit. Comparison of two film versions of romeo and juliet shakespeares play romeo.
Can you compare and contrast romeo and juliets play to its. Also, friar john in the play is held captive in a small town due to the black plague however. Romeo and juliets movies differences and similarities uploaded by gemstone on mar 05, 2007. A comparison grid and essay frame focusing on the fight scene in act 1 scene 1. Check out shmoop s visual take on what its all about. In the 1968 version, romeo first sees juliet on the dance floor. Romeo and juliet balcony scene comparecontrast prezi. Romeo and juliet film 1996 what two groups of people hold an ancient grudge.
Apr 17, 2014 last night i watched romeo and juliet 20 film directed by carlo carlei. Retellings of romeo and juliet, ranked the washington post. Books and movies have similarities and differences. As the music quickened, the film used rhythmically equal edits to keep up with the musics pace. Get an answer for what are five differences between the two film adaptations of romeo and juliet. In the 1996 baz luhrman film of romeo and juliet, mercutio gives romeo a pill with a heart on it. In baz luhrmanns 1996 film shakespeares famous play is updated to the hip modern suburb of verona still retaining its original dialogue.
After reading the play romeo and juliet, students will view the film and analyze the differences. Comparing two film versions of romeo and juliet essay. Compare romeo and juliet in romeo and juliet chart. There will be many different opinions about which version of romeo and juliet is best, and many valid arguments in support of them. If i had to pick a favourite it would probably be the 1968 version because it resembles the original play written by shakespeare a lot more than the 1996 version and it better represented the whole idea of the balcony scene compared to the 1996. Compare and contrast reading a book and watching a film.
His 1600s audience wouldve already known the story of romeo and juliet from a famous poem of the time, so this information would not have ruined the experience. Viewing a movie as a text is entertaining and educational. While watching the latest version i thought a lot about the 1968 version which is similar to the 20 film, the 20 film is a. At this point, we will have read act 1 and watched and heard two versions of the same scenes, while taking notes on the worksheet. Therefore, one way to learn more about works of art is to compare and contrast them.
A comparison of two film versions of romeo and juliet by. I want students to think about their answer honest before anyone can influence their reactions. Zeffirelli cut nearly twothirds of shakespeares lines, but many critics felt this film was a sensitive adaptation of the text. Rww romeo and juliet act questions and answers flashcards. In the 1996 film version, the capulet ball is a costume party, where juliet is dressed as an angel, romeo as a knight in shining armor, and paris as an astronaut. The question and answer section for romeo and juliet film 1996 is a great resource to.
Please notethe formatting looks strange in the thumbnails, but the original file is ok. Essay examples of romeo and juliet movie comparison essaybot. Its still one of the most visually arresting film versions of romeo and juliet, and is regarded by many as the best alltime film adaptation. While the 1968 classical version of shakespeares romeo and juliet should be appreciated, the modern version portrays the. Comparing the starts of two film versions of romeo and juliet romeo and juliet is a timeless, classical love story written by the unmatched author, william shakespeare. Romeo and juliet film guiding worksheet luhrmann by. Comparison of two film versions of romeo and juliet essay. Study help film versions adaptations of shakespeares plays and other works have been featured in nearly 500 films andor videos worldwide. Romeo and juliet forge onward in pursuit of their love empowered to dare cross thresholds that have before been barriers. Screenshots from romeo and juliet balcony scene compare and contrast the film from 1996 was, in some ways, very different from the other two adaptations.
First of all, romeo and juliet is so famous and popular all around the world, and the two main charactersromeo and juliet are so wellknown that even people who have no idea about theatre or the original piece of work know they are tragic lovers whose. In this play, love supersede other characteristics such as loyalty, emotions etc. West side story, the modern retelling of william shakespeares romeo and juliet, won ten academy awards for its rousing depiction of the tale of starcrossed lovers. Get an answer for compare and contrast the character of romeo in one of the original film versions of romeo and juliet with the leonardo dicaprio version. Can you compare the zeffirelli and luhrmann versions of romeo. Compare and contrast the characters of romeo and juliet how. Can you compare the zeffirelli and luhrmann versions of. The whole play is intertwined on the romantic love between romeo and juliet at their first sight.
In the prologue, shakespeare tells us that out two title characters are going to kill themselves. One of the reasons for its success was due to the fact the actors were young, as in shakespeares original version. Romeo and juliets movies differences and similarities. The zeffirelli version is more classic and was made in 1968. At the beginning of the play, he mopes over his hopeless. What are five differences between the two film adaptations. Compare and contrast the character of romeo in one. Compare and contrast the characters of romeo and juliet. How do the costumes in franco zeffirellis film version of shakespeares romeo and juliet.
The two versions of romeo and juliet we saw were the franco zeffirelli version of 1968. Essay there are many differences and similarities between luhrmanns 1996 version of romeo and juliet, and zeferellis 1968 version. This opens up a bunch of fun and criticalthinking conversation about why the filmmakers would change parts of the play for the film. Comparing the starts of two film versions of romeo and juliet. What are five differences between the two film adaptations of. At this point, we will have read act 1 and watched and heard two versions of the same scenes. In franco zeffirellis 1968 version of romeo and juliet, is a traditional adaptation of shakespeares original romeo and juliet, with some variations. Romeo and juliet in harlem 2015 film, directed by aleta chapelle the first shakespeare feature film adaptation of romeo and juliet with a complete cast of color that stays true to the language and storyline. In baz lurhmanns version of romeo and juliet he starts with a dark room with a television producing static noise.
Two differences between the play romeo and juliet and the. Jun 08, 2016 i will be comparing this scene as depicted in the opening sequences of two film versions. With references to touching the void and another book. The love occurs between romeo and juliet, the children of the two families who have an ancient grudge. Movie compare and contrast there are many similarities and.
The play romeo and juliet by william shakespeare was written around the year 1595. The question and answer section for romeo and juliet film 1996 is a great resource to ask questions, find answers, and discuss the novel. Comparing shakespeares play to luhrmanns romeo and juliet. A comparison of the two film versions of romeo and juliet 1789 words 8 pages. Franco zeffirelli s film released in 1968 and set in the italian renaissance. May 14, 2016 after reading the play romeo and juliet, students will view the film and analyze the differences. He is loyal to his friends, but his behavior is somewhat unpredictable. Compare and contrast the two film versions of romeo and juliet by franco zeffirelli and baz luhrmann essay sample. Trying to imagine compare romeo and juliet in romeo and juliet. This exam paper sets out to analyse and compare the film adaptations of the.
The play romeo and juliet by william shakespeare was. Here are the best, and most noteworthy, versions of romeo and juliet that can help you study and better understand the play. Everyone loves a classic love story like romeo and juliet. Leonardo dicaprio baz luhrmann the balcony scene baz luhrmanns interpretation of romeo and juliet was more successful in positioning the audience to. A party at the capulets juliets family is being held and a crush of romeos, rosaline is to be attending. Comparison of two film versions of romeo and juliet shakespeares play romeo and juliet was made into a film by two different directors. When we read a book we create a visual image in our heads, whereas when we watch a movie the image is. Great art borrows from the past and gives to the future. Study help film versions adaptations of shakespeares plays and other works have been featured in nearly 500 films and or videos worldwide. Romeo and juliet film guiding worksheet luhrmann by gitana. Romeo and juliet movies and play comparison hubpages. Compare the acting, setting, cinematography, scenery and costumes. Jun 07, 2009 compare the acting, setting, cinematography, scenery and costumes.
Shelby campbell romeo and juliet is a tragic play written by the very famous william shakespeare. The updated luhrmann picture best captures the essence of shakespeare for the present day viewer. Romeo and juliet film 1996 questions and answers the question and answer sections of our study guides are a great resource to ask questions, find answers, and discuss literature. In conclusion, both versions of romeo and juliet portrayed the balcony scene in two different ways. Romeo and juliet act ii scene ii compare and contrast. Many of shakespeares works are considered literary classics, but none are more loved, well known than romeo and juliet. Startled by a noise, romeo then panics and, in attempt to hide. Over the years it has been remade into movies, ballets and childrens books. To believe in love, to be ready to give up anything for it, to be willing to risk your life for it, is the ultimate tragedy. Compare two film versions of romeo and juliet teachit english. This allows you to see the works as individual parts of a larger whole. I select this for a couple of reasons that are listed as the following. Compare and contrast of two film versions of romeo and juliet. In fact, many scholars say that knowing the deaths are coming actually improves the play.
Paris is also, most probably, well connected politically, making him a good family contact for capulet and his wife. Romeo is a passionate, extreme, excitable, intelligent, and moody young man, wellliked and admired throughout verona. The 10 greatest productions of romeo and juliet of all time. There are two movies that each take different approaches to this classic story of two forbidden lovers. In romeo and juliet, what are the similarities and. I will be comparing this scene as depicted in the opening sequences of two film versions. It tells the story of two starcrossed lovers as they try to find a place in the world together without dealing with the wrath of heir families rivalry. Romeoparis compare and contrast flashcards quizlet. This is a question which i shall seek to respond to, if i cannot answer it, in the progress of this paper.
Apr 20, 20 romeo and juliet by william shakespeare is a loved classic. A comparison of two film versions of act 3 scene 5 of william shakespeares romeo and juliet the two versions i have studied are franco zeffirellis paramount film and alvin rakoffs bbc version. That makes shakespeare the most filmed playwright of all time. Some people will prefer film or tv adaptations, others will be. In the beginning of the scene, romeo enters over the fence and into the area near the pool behind juliets house. Which version of romeo and juliet is better answers. Long shots showed the dancing, and the camera then followed romeo and juliet s faces. Romeo and juliet comparison with play 1968 movie and 1996. Please prove your answer with reference to movies and dramas. Romeo and juliet play and movie comparison film studies essay.
William shakespeares romeo and juliet is a cherished piece of literature that has been remade into movies many times throughout history. In the older movie, romeo does not slay paris before entering the capulet tomb as he does in the play. After the party romeo jumps out of the car to see juliet. Love is obviously the dominating and most vital theme of this play. We will take a few minutes to debrief this film specifically, much like we did with the last one sl. First, students fill in the organizer after watching the 1968 version, then as they watch the 1996 film, they contrast the movies. At the party, juliet doesnt ask who romeo was, instead nurse just automatically knows who he is. This article will compare and contrast between the play itself and two famous romeo and juliet movies. There are four main themes in the play of romeo and juliet.
Compare and contrast two film adaptations for act 1 scene 5 of. Both zeffirellis and luhrmanns film versions of romeo and juliet use this. Romeo and juliet comparison paper free essay example. The musical is about two rival gangs, with marias brother being the head of the sharks. Can you compare and contrast romeo and juliets play to. This romeo and juliet and west side story compare and contrast graphic organizer is suitable for 8th 12th grade. I designed this worksheet to help students find and note differences between the. Baz luhrmann directed the 1996 version, also known as the mtv romeo juliet this version is very modernized, but keeps the language intact with few changes. William shakespeares play romeo and juliet has been adapted to film and television many times. In 1968 and 1996 movies were created by directors zefferelli 1968, and baz luhrmann 1996. Romeo and juliet movie comparison essay 650 words bartleby.
The major differences between the two movies romeo and juliet who were made by franco zefferelli in 1968 and baz luhrmann in 1996, are that they were interpreted in different ways because the historical and social context of the two films which may have influenced the two directors to portray their movies the way they did. How do i compare baz luhrmanns and franco zeffirellis versions of. Comparing to versions of romeo and juliet the star crossed lovers, romeo and juliet, are presented in two famous movie productions. Thats right, as this movie is a unique and exciting adaptation of shakespeares romeo and juliet. Romeo and juliet by william shakespeare is a loved classic. Last night i watched romeo and juliet 20 film directed by carlo carlei. The renowned william shakespeares play, romeo and juliet was directed into two movie versions. I believe franco zeffirellis romeo and juliet is the most exciting film of shakespeare ever made. But how closely does the plot align to its source material. Please give examples of the differences and use detail. How do i compare baz luhrmanns and franco zeffirellis.
691 58 1071 1171 479 1574 1447 300 1568 668 1274 527 667 1228 623 91 1496 433 234 1186 1411 375 1419 843 633 662 1193 418 334 1045 694 144 915 813 615 435 39 809 458